🏠 NEET Home

NEET 2027 · Physics · Moving Charges & Magnetism

Four Doubts,
Solved Fully

Each one worked through the same seven steps — what you were given, what is actually being asked, the idea underneath, the arithmetic in small pieces, the shortcuts that would have got you there faster, the answer, and a diagram that moves.

Problem 1

Field at the centre of a flat spiral coil

JEE Main · 30 June 2022 (I)
A coil of n turns is wound tightly as a spiral with inner radius r₁ and outer radius r₂. A current I flows. Find the magnetic field at its centre.

1Given

  • n turns, wound tightly as a flat spiral
  • Inner radius r₁, outer radius r₂ (with r₂ > r₁)
  • Current I in every turn
  • Implicit: the turns are spread evenly across the radial width (r₂ − r₁)
  • Implicit: each turn is close enough to a full circle to use the loop formula

2Asked

The magnetic field B at the centre of the spiral.

3Concept

One circular loop of radius r gives a field at its centre of B = μ0I / 2r. But here every turn sits at a different radius, so there is no single r to plug in.

So do what Biot–Savart always asks: chop the spiral into thin rings, work out what one ring gives, and add them all up. Every turn carries current the same way round, so all their fields point the same way and simply add as numbers — no vectors needed.

4Method & baby steps

  1. How many turns lie in a thin ring between r and r + dr?
    n turns are spread over a width of (r₂ − r₁) so turns per unit width = n / (r₂ − r₁) in a slice of width dr: dN = n dr / (r₂ − r₁)
  2. What field does that thin ring make?
    one loop of radius r gives μ₀I / 2r dN loops of radius r give dB = μ₀ I dN / 2r substitute dN: dB = μ₀ n I dr / 2r(r₂ − r₁)
  3. Add up every ring from r₁ out to r₂
    pull the constants outside: B = μ₀nI / 2(r₂ − r₁) × ∫ dr/r from r₁ to r₂
  4. Do the integral — this is the only one that gives a log
    ∫ dr/r = ln r evaluated: ln r₂ − ln r₁ = ln(r₂/r₁)
  5. Put it together
    B = μ₀nI / 2(r₂ − r₁) · ln(r₂/r₁)

5Easy tricks & shortcuts

Spot the log before you integrate. Whenever a quantity is spread evenly across a range and the formula divides by that same variable, a natural logarithm is coming. ∫dr/r is the only integral in this chapter that produces one.
Kill three options in ten seconds. (b) contains no r₁ at all — the inner radius must matter. (c) has ln(r₁/r₂), which is negative because r₂ > r₁ — a magnitude cannot be negative. (a) has no logarithm, so it cannot come from a 1/r integral.
Limit check. Squeeze the spiral until all turns sit at one radius: put r₂ = r₁ + δ with δ tiny. Then ln(1 + δ/r₁) ≈ δ/r₁, and B → μ0nI/2δ × δ/r₁ = μ0nI / 2r₁ — exactly the tight-coil formula. The answer passes.

6Solution

Answer

Option (d)

B = μ0nI / 2(r₂ − r₁) × loge(r₂/r₁). Verified against a numerical integration of the ring sum.

7Diagram

A flat spiral coil, chopped into thin ringsr₁r₂n turns spread evenly from r₁ out to r₂one thin ring at radius rdN = n dr / (r₂ − r₁)dB = μ₀ I dN / 2radd every ring, r₁ → r₂∫ dr/r gives ln(r₂/r₁)B = μ₀nI / 2(r₂−r₁) · ln(r₂/r₁)
Each grey ring is one slice of the spiral. The brass ring sweeps from r₁ to r₂ — the sum of all those slices is the answer.

Problem 2

Electron deflected by a short field region

JEE Main · 12 April 2019 (II)
An electron with 100 eV of energy moves along the x-axis and enters a field B = 1.5×10−3 T at S, which extends from x = 0 to x = 2 cm. It lands at Q on a screen 8 cm from S. Find the distance d between P and Q.

1Given

  • Electron: charge e = 1.6 × 10−19 C, mass m = 9.1 × 10−31 kg
  • Initial kinetic energy K = 100 eV
  • Field B = 1.5 × 10−3 T, along (out of the page)
  • Field exists only between x = 0 and x = 2 cm
  • Screen is 8 cm from S → so the field-free drift is 8 − 2 = 6 cm
  • Implicit: P is where the electron would have landed undeflected

2Asked

The distance d = PQ measured on the screen.

3Concept

The journey has two quite different halves, and the whole difficulty of the question is remembering that.

  • Inside the field (2 cm): a circular arc of radius r = mv/eB. The electron gains both a sideways shift and a slope.
  • After the field (6 cm): no force at all, so a perfectly straight line at whatever slope it left with.

The total deflection is the sum of the two. Forget the first part and you land on one of the wrong options that has been placed there deliberately.

4Method & baby steps

  1. Turn the energy into a speed
    K = 100 eV = 100 × 1.6×10⁻¹⁹ = 1.6 × 10⁻¹⁷ J v = √(2K/m) = √(2 × 1.6×10⁻¹⁷ ÷ 9.1×10⁻³¹) = √(3.52 × 10¹³) = 5.93 × 10⁶ m/s
  2. Find the radius of the arc
    r = mv / eB = (9.1×10⁻³¹ × 5.93×10⁶) ÷ (1.6×10⁻¹⁹ × 1.5×10⁻³) = 5.40×10⁻²⁴ ÷ 2.40×10⁻²² = 0.0225 m = 2.25 cm
  3. Find the angle it has turned through on leaving the field
    horizontal distance covered in the field = 2 cm sin θ = 2 / 2.25 = 0.889 θ = 62.8° cos θ = 0.458 tan θ = 1.94
  4. Deflection gained INSIDE the field
    y₁ = r − r cos θ = r(1 − cos θ) = 2.25 × (1 − 0.458) = 2.25 × 0.542 = 1.22 cm
  5. Deflection gained while drifting the remaining 6 cm
    y₂ = (8 − 2) × tan θ = 6 × 1.94 = 11.65 cm
  6. Add the two
    d = y₁ + y₂ = 1.22 + 11.65 = 12.87 cm

5Easy tricks & shortcuts

Learn one number. An electron with 100 eV of energy travels at about 5.9 × 106 m/s. In general v = √(2eV/m), so a 400 eV electron is exactly twice as fast, a 25 eV one exactly half.
Estimate before you finish. Once you see r ≈ 2.25 cm against a 2 cm field width, sin θ is nearly 0.9 and tan θ is nearly 2. So the drift alone is roughly 6 × 2 = 12 cm. Only one option is anywhere near that.
The wrong options are diagnostic. (d) 2.25 cm is the radius. (c) 1.22 cm is y₁ on its own. (a) 11.65 cm is y₂ on its own — the trap for anyone who forgets the electron was already displaced when it left the field. If you picked one of these, you know exactly which step you skipped.

6Solution

Answer

Option (b) — d ≈ 12.87 cm

y₁ = 1.22 cm gained inside the field, plus y₂ = 11.65 cm gained over the 6 cm drift.

7Diagram

Electron curving inside the field, then drifting to the screenB out of pageSPQd2 cm of field8 cm from S to the screenthen a straight line — no force out here
Curved inside the field, straight outside it. Both stretches contribute to d (drawn schematically, not to scale).

Problem 3

Trajectory through two opposite field regions

JEE Advanced style · multiple choice
B = B₀ĵ exists for a < x < 2a, and B = −B₀ĵ for 2a < x < 3a. A positive charge with v = v₀î enters at x = a. Which graph shows its path?

1Given

  • Region 1 (a < x < 2a): B = +B₀ ĵ
  • Region 2 (2a < x < 3a): B = −B₀ ĵ
  • Charge is positive
  • Enters at x = a with v = v₀ î (purely along +x)
  • The graphs are drawn in the x–z plane

2Asked

Which of the four sketched trajectories is correct.

3Concept

Two ideas settle this without any calculation.

  • Direction. F = q(v × B). With v along x and B along y, the force is along z. Get its sign and half the options die.
  • Reversal. Flipping B flips the direction of turning, not the sign of the velocity the particle has already built up. So the curve changes its bend, but z carries on increasing.

Also worth holding on to: the magnetic force does no work, so the speed never changes — only the direction.

4Method & baby steps

  1. Get the initial force direction
    F = q (v × B) = q (v₀ î × B₀ ĵ) = q v₀ B₀ (î × ĵ) and î × ĵ = k̂, so F is along +z — the particle curves UPWARD
  2. Eliminate immediately
    options (b) and (d) show the path going DOWN → both are out
  3. What happens across Region 1 (a to 2a)
    velocity rotates steadily from +x toward +z vz grows from 0 upward so the curve gets steeper — concave up
  4. What happens across Region 2 (2a to 3a)
    B has flipped sign, so the turning reverses velocity now rotates back from +z toward +x vz shrinks toward zero — but stays POSITIVE so the curve flattens — concave down
  5. Does z ever come back down?
    z would only fall if vz went NEGATIVE reversing B reverses the RATE of turning, not vz itself vz only decays back toward zero so z rises the whole way — option (c) is out
  6. The surviving shape
    rises, steepens, inflects at 2a, then flattens an S-curve that keeps climbing → option (a)

5Easy tricks & shortcuts

Never compute a trajectory question — eliminate it. One cross product gives the sign and removes half the options. One sentence about whether z can fall removes most of the rest.
The trap in option (c). It is tempting to think ‘the field reversed, so the particle comes back down’. It does not. Reversing B reverses the curvature, which is about the second derivative. The first derivative, vz, is still positive and merely decays.
Keep the ring handy. î × ĵ = , ĵ × k̂ = î, k̂ × î = ĵ. Forward round the ring is plus; backwards is minus.

6Solution

Answer

Option (a)

An upward S-curve: concave up through the first region, an inflection at x = 2a, then concave down through the second — with z increasing throughout.

7Diagram

Trajectory through two oppositely directed field regionsxza2a3aB = +B₀ ĵB = −B₀ ĵbends one waybends backF = qv×B is +zinflectionz never falls — the slope only rises, then flattens
Green region bends it one way, red region bends it back. The height never decreases.

Problem 4

How far into Region II does the particle get?

JEE Advanced 2008 · more than one correct
A particle of mass m and charge q, moving at speed v, enters Region II normal to the boundary. Region II has a uniform field B perpendicular to the page and is of width ℓ. Which statements are correct?

1Given

  • Mass m, charge q, speed v
  • Enters Region II normal to the boundary — this word is the key to the whole question
  • Region II: uniform B, perpendicular to the page, width
  • Regions I and III are field free
  • Implicit: the speed never changes, since a magnetic force does no work

2Asked

Which of the four statements (a)–(d) are correct. More than one may be.

3Concept

Inside Region II the particle travels on a circle of radius r = mv/qB. Everything follows from one geometric fact:

Because it enters normal to the boundary, the centre of that circle lies on the boundary itself. So the deepest the particle can ever penetrate is exactly one radius. Compare r with ℓ and every part of the question answers itself.

4Method & baby steps

  1. Fix the geometry
    r = mv / qB entering normal ⇒ centre of the circle sits ON the entry boundary ⇒ maximum penetration depth = exactly r
  2. Condition to reach Region III → tests (a) and (b)
    needs r > ℓ mv / qB > ℓ v > qℓB / m so (a) is CORRECT and (b) is WRONG
  3. Path length inside Region II → tests (c)
    if r < ℓ : it does a HALF circle and returns path length = πr, which grows with r largest as r → ℓ : πℓ ≈ 3.14 ℓ if r > ℓ : it turns through θ with sin θ = ℓ/r path length = rθ as r → ℓ from above: θ → 90°, path → 1.57 ℓ so the path length is longest exactly at r = ℓ v = qℓB / m → (c) is CORRECT
  4. Time spent when it comes back → tests (d)
    coming back means a complete half circle t = T/2 = (1/2)(2πm / qB) = πm / qB no v anywhere in it → same for every speed that returns → (d) is CORRECT

5Easy tricks & shortcuts

‘Normal to the boundary’ is a gift. It puts the circle’s centre on the boundary, so penetration depth = r exactly, with no geometry to do. Had it entered at an angle, you would have had to work much harder.
Any ‘how deep does it get’ question reduces to comparing r = mv/qB against the width of the region. That single comparison usually decides every part of the question at once.
When a time question involves a half circle, the speed always cancels, because T = 2πm/qB contains no v. It is the very same fact that lets a cyclotron run at one fixed frequency.
Why the maximum sits exactly at r = ℓ. The path length jumps down as r crosses ℓ — from about 3.14ℓ (a half circle) to about 1.57ℓ (a quarter turn). A quantity that leaps downward at a boundary has its maximum right at that boundary.

6Solution

Answer

(a), (c) and (d)

Only statement (b) is wrong — it has the inequality the wrong way round.

7Diagram

Small radius returns; large radius crosses into Region IIIr < ℓ — turns backr > ℓ — gets throughhalf circle, time = πm/qBneeds v > qℓB/m
Left: the radius is too small, so it loops back into Region I. Right: a bigger radius carries it through to Region III.